The next evening, she googled it, after carefully inspecting the note the tooth fairy had left to see if any of the handwriting matched Dave's or my mine. She went to ASK.com and there she found all sorts of question and answers, all basically saying that it is not real, and that the Easter Bunny, Leprechauns and Santa are also not real.
Today, we sat down to have the conversation about all these magical characters. I was not prepared & completely afraid of saying something wrong. I am so super lucky that she is super smart & super mature to have completely understood the entire explanation.
We ended the conversation with her realizing that Mommy & Daddy were the ones who really did give the big gift each year at Christmas and the ones who hide all the eggs, and stuff them...and that it's pretty awesome of us!!! :)